Deplatforming doesn't work. We must confront our demons.
Progressive censors failed to suppress our political demons. It's finally time to confront them.
reason.com
---
When Donald Trump was kicked off social media in 2021, liberal pundit Matthew Yglesias tweeted, "It's kinda weird that deplatforming Trump just like completely worked with no visible downside whatsoever." Two years later, Fox News fired Tucker Carlson, and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D–N.Y.) celebrated that "deplatforming works," though she worried about the long-term implications.
"I also kind of feel like I'm waiting for the cut scene at the end of a Marvel movie after all the credits have rolled, and then you like see the villain's hand reemerge," said Ocasio-Cortez.
As it turns out, every major star gets a sequel. Trump is back in the White House, and Carlson has a bigger audience than ever before.
What we've learned is that deplatforming doesn't work.
In 2021, I published a video at Reason predicting this backfire effect, comparing the media ecosystem to Freud's theory of the unconscious:
Sigmund Freud theorized that when thoughts or experiences are repressed, they inevitably resurface in more deranged and damaging forms. When our dominant communication platforms seek to repress widely held beliefs and opinions, those beliefs and opinions aren't likely to simply disappear but rather reemerge elsewhere.
What we've learned since the Great Deplatforming of 2021, and the subsequent rise of extremist commentators like Nick Fuentes, is that the best way to exorcise our demons is to confront them head-on.
Producer: Zach Weissmueller
Video editor: John Osterdhoudt
Graphics: Lex Villena
reason.com
---
When Donald Trump was kicked off social media in 2021, liberal pundit Matthew Yglesias tweeted, "It's kinda weird that deplatforming Trump just like completely worked with no visible downside whatsoever." Two years later, Fox News fired Tucker Carlson, and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D–N.Y.) celebrated that "deplatforming works," though she worried about the long-term implications.
"I also kind of feel like I'm waiting for the cut scene at the end of a Marvel movie after all the credits have rolled, and then you like see the villain's hand reemerge," said Ocasio-Cortez.
As it turns out, every major star gets a sequel. Trump is back in the White House, and Carlson has a bigger audience than ever before.
What we've learned is that deplatforming doesn't work.
In 2021, I published a video at Reason predicting this backfire effect, comparing the media ecosystem to Freud's theory of the unconscious:
Sigmund Freud theorized that when thoughts or experiences are repressed, they inevitably resurface in more deranged and damaging forms. When our dominant communication platforms seek to repress widely held beliefs and opinions, those beliefs and opinions aren't likely to simply disappear but rather reemerge elsewhere.
What we've learned since the Great Deplatforming of 2021, and the subsequent rise of extremist commentators like Nick Fuentes, is that the best way to exorcise our demons is to confront them head-on.
Producer: Zach Weissmueller
Video editor: John Osterdhoudt
Graphics: Lex Villena
ReasonTV
Meet the biohackers, brewers, bitcoiners, makers, growers, freaks, and visionaries exploring new ways of living in an increasingly individualistic world. Watch investigative stories about the bureaucrats and busybodies fighting for control over our lives....